I
Imagine with me a forty-three-year-old man named Mark. Mark’s life has not gone the way he planned. He is in the midst of a contentious divorce and only gets to see his seven- and nine-year-old kids every other weekend while he and his wife work out the final custody agreement. The sports bets he placed “just for fun” in high school became a full-blown online gambling addiction that strained his finances and then his marriage. He declares bankruptcy and is working as many shifts as possible at the hardware store just to make ends meet. Strained and alone, he relies a little too much on Michelob Lights in the evenings to take the edge off. He hasn’t been to church in years and, really, hasn’t ever considered it.
Mark never imagined this is where he would be in midlife. But here he is.
Image 1: The Time Traveller
Now imagine a youth pastor, Pastor Tim, who can travel back in time. Today, he gets the necessary 1.21 gigawatts of power for his souped-up DeLorean and travels back to 1998, when our friend Mark is still just a freshman in high school. Pastor Tim is going back to help address what went wrong in Mark’s teenage years so that his life might not become the mess it is by 2026.
To blend into 1998 seamlessly, time-travelling Tim has a goatee, wears a bright polo shirt that matches perfectly with his puka-shell necklace, plays guitar, and shows up to Mark’s cross-country meet to support him. Tim then gets someone who attends the local church to invite teenage Mark to youth group that Sunday.
Mark’s family isn’t the churchgoing type. They occasionally go to a candlelight Christmas Eve service, but that’s it. Mark has never imagined himself as someone who would attend a church youth group, but he thinks Tim is nice—a little weird, but the good kind of weird. Plus he’s heard there are cute girls at the church, so he accepts the invitation and gives it a shot. Mark has a blast at youth group. After attending the group’s fall retreat and hearing about God’s offer of salvation through faith in Jesus Christ, he makes the decision to follow.
As time goes on, Mark becomes great friends with the others in the group. He teaches himself guitar and plays in the youth group worship band. He goes off to college, and after a freshman year where he gets a little too caught up in the party scene, he joins a college ministry. He marries a girl and raises a family; his marriage isn’t perfect, and he still gets into sports gambling after college but confesses his problems to the men’s group he meets with each week. He gets the help he needs, and Mark and his wife see a counsellor once a month to work on their issues. They send their kids to their church’s kids ministry, and Mark looks forward to when they’ll one day join the youth ministry.
So why in the name of Marty McFly have I asked you to go on this hypothetical journey? Because, to some extent, youth ministry’s transformative potential makes the most sense when we consider its effects over the arc of an individual’s life in community.
Youth ministry is a relatively recent phenomenon. Ministry geared exclusively to children gained popularity with the Sunday school movement of the nineteenth century. Toward the middle of the twentieth century, parachurch organizations like Young Life and Youth for Christ were the first to target teenagers specifically, leading local churches to ask, What can we be doing to minister to the youth in our congregations? Youth groups began to take off in the seventies. Some churches even developed budgets to hire a new ministry specimen: the youth pastor.
Youth ministry, like any ministry, does not guarantee a happy ending or solve every problem. I am aware of the many critiques of youth ministry. In fact, those critiques are an industry unto themselves, rightly pointing out the theological thinness, the misguided focus on entertainment over spiritual discipline, and the statistical record showing how many young people have walked away from the church since the inception of youth ministry. The critiques are real and need to be considered and addressed seriously. But as a frontline worker in this field, I want to show that the worst versions of a thing should not define what it could—or should—be. Youth ministry at its best is the process of getting hold of the heart of a teenager and directing them into a church—a community of Christ followers—that will continue to exert a formative role their entire life. Research has indicated that consistent youth group participation, particularly where a student is in a small group led by a trained adult, leads to a lasting faith.
Youth ministry’s transformative potential makes the most sense when we consider its effects over the arc of an individual’s life in community.
I worked as a high school youth pastor for twenty-five years. That is roughly twenty-five more years than I imagined I’d be a youth pastor. I have met a lot of Marks during that time. I could never travel in time, but watching first-hand this kind of life transformation in teenagers is precisely what kept me committed to youth ministry as a career for so long. A few of these Marks whom I met in the late nineties are some of my dearest friends to this day.
The time traveller, though, is only one image that helps us understand the transformative work of youth ministry. There are at least two other images I find helpful in explaining healthy youth ministry.
Image 2: Belonging in the Moving Stream
I grew up in Austin, Texas, and usually about once a summer we’d drive down I-35 to New Braunfels to float the Guadalupe River. The Guadalupe (a good Texan knows it’s pronounced “GWOD-a-loop”) is about thirty feet wide, with seventy-five-foot cypress trees lining the banks. After renting your inner tube (plus an extra one for the group with a hard bottom for your cooler), you simply float your way down to where someone picks you up to take you back to your car.
That’s the event. It’s very fun. Very Texas.
So how is this like youth ministry?
Every follower of Christ enters the flow of a river that ends up in the kingdom of God. The power of youth ministry is that a youth can enter a spot in the river along with others and find the joy of the experience of floating in the current early in life. There are, of course, entry points at other places farther down the river, but those spots aren’t always as obvious; and sometimes the longer people wait, the more unlikely their entrance into the water becomes. They might conclude, “Joining this river just isn’t for me.”
The river is like the church, God’s primary plan for how followers of Christ move toward their final home with God. And when someone participates in youth ministry—I’m thinking primarily here of a young person raised in the church—they often experience what it’s like to be moved along with the current of the river.
In community, youth get the opportunity to worship God. They hear the word of God preached. They’re regularly challenged to apply it to their lives, often through time in a small group. They’re encouraged to serve others, to share their faith with their friends, and, as they mature into adults, to commit to this journey down the river.
In general, youth who grow up in a church with a healthy youth ministry have the opportunity to experience life with God for themselves: They take the risk of walking into the water even though they’re not sure where exactly it will take them, and find that when they do, this is what they were made for.
No image is perfect. The analogy breaks down in plenty of ways because we also know that following Jesus isn’t about passively floating—it’s about actively following. So picture this river with occasional rapids, some quite treacherous. But don’t get caught up in the (river) weeds! A well-functioning youth ministry provides young people with an experience of an encounter with a real, present, active God moving in and through his gathered people. His church. Ideally, this experience leads them to a lifetime of moving in God’s current.
Teenagers, even those raised in stable, churched homes, experience feelings of isolation, loneliness, and uncertainty about their identity. They wonder: Where do I belong? For many, the answers are found in youth ministry.
I watched this happen before my very eyes when I stumbled into a part-time job as a worship leader for a youth group while I was in seminary. I enjoyed the students there, but I had my eye on what I believed was a bigger prize. I mean, I was getting my master of divinity. Working as a youth pastor felt like someone in medical school taking a job as a high school nurse. “I will have my MDiv,” I thought. “I’ll be so advanced. And important.”
But when summer came, the youth pastor position came open. I still needed a job, so I became an accidental youth pastor, which I thought might last twelve to eighteen more months at the most.
One of the requests the church made was that I attend a mission trip to Tijuana, Mexico, to build a home with a team of thirty, half families and half students. That sounded like fun, so I agreed, not knowing that this trip would change absolutely everything about my life.
If you’ve been on a youth group mission trip, you might know what I’m referring to. While our group partnered with a local church to minister to the community, so many incredible things happened at once: A precious family received a new home. Neighbourhood families heard the good news of the Savior Jesus. And in the context of coming together on a common mission to be the hands and feet of Christ for that week, the students developed a connection to one another, and to God, that went beyond a normal post-retreat “God high.” When we returned, the students were passionate about their faith and started inviting their friends to join us on Sunday nights. This little church youth group of twenty in a basement eventually grew to fifty and larger.
It’s common to attend church in our community, but less common to have a faith that’s central to one’s life. So becoming a committed Christian wouldn’t exactly help you climb any social ladders. Despite this, the students, almost as one, entered the Guadalupe of faith and began calling to others on the banks of the river: “Come on in—the water’s great!” They had developed a real sense of belonging, both to God and to each other. What naturally flowed out of that was a desire to invite others into it.
Creating an environment of belonging is no small thing. The order for participation in youth ministries used to be as follows: believe, behave, belong. That is, we need you to (1) believe what we believe (and don’t ask so many questions!) and (2) behave better (you’re a Christian now, after all), and then (3) once the secret committee has met and you’ve adequately proved yourself, we’ll vote on whether we’ll let you belong to our club.
The proper paradigm is this: belong, believe, become. That is, first and foremost, if you want to be part of our group, you can. Anyone can belong here. Just grab your tube and jump in the water. We want you here no matter what you believe. Once students feel welcomed unconditionally, they’re more likely to open their hearts up to investigating Christian beliefs and more willing to entertain some of these seemingly strange ideas. That leads students to becoming the people God made them to be.
Once students feel welcomed unconditionally, they’re more likely to open their hearts up to investigating Christian beliefs and more willing to entertain some of these seemingly strange ideas.
This is what I saw happen after that mission trip, and it’s continued to this day, decades later. Students came home from Mexico with a heart to invite others, to forgive the people who hurt them, to love people who weren’t kind to them, and to engage in spiritual practices that led them closer to God.
So many students entered this flowing river of God’s mercy, and by his grace, many are still on that river today. Not all students, however, will want to enter that stream in middle school or high school, which brings us to our final image.
Image 3: Scattered Seeds
Jesus talks about how the kingdom of God is like a farmer who scatters his seeds, but not all of them end up in good soil.
Any youth pastor knows that while there are plenty of seeds that find great soil, many don’t. To be a youth pastor is to experience the rejection of students who are just not interested.
But a good youth pastor also knows that their labour isn’t in vain. Sometimes the growth happens many years later. Your job is not to control the outcomes; it’s to provide opportunities for students to get a taste of what life in the kingdom is like, and leave the growth and fruit to God.
In my context, this taste of life in the kingdom would regularly happen on these mission trips. For our entry-level trip, which involved building a home for a family, anyone could participate regardless of commitment level, so it would often attract students who weren’t regularly involved.
One such student—I’ll call her Cindy—grew up in the church but didn’t have many friends in the youth group and never connected. She attended the mission trip the summer after her senior year. I expected her to be standoffish but to my surprise found her open and present. During our building days, she’d regularly stop what she was doing to exclaim, “I can’t believe how amazing this is! I didn’t expect to enjoy doing ministry this much!” Sensing her openness, I met with her a couple of times after the trip, before she moved on to college. But then we mostly lost touch. I later heard that she was attending a church with her husband and kids, but I didn’t know much else.
Out of nowhere, about eighteen months ago, she sent me a text message, which read:
Unbeknown to me, Cindy’s family had lost their home and all their possessions in the California wildfires. And even though I hadn’t been in touch with her lately, she thought back on her faith. She thought of me.
My internal response was: Me? What did I do?! I was just nice to her on a mission trip, which is a very low bar—it was literally my job.
But that was a scattered seed. It landed in a place I didn’t even know.
A few months after I received that text, I was visiting California and reached out to Cindy. I got to spend time with her and her family over a meal. She shared some things I’d told her in our meeting together that had made an impact (I had forgotten all of it, but she hadn’t), and she reiterated that the mission trip was the planted seed that was crucial for her journey.
But get this. The very next morning I went for a walk at the beach and just happened to walk right past another former youth group student, who was basically the same kind of student as Cindy, about ten years younger: She grew up in the church but never connected at youth group outside of a couple mission trips.
I’d lost touch with her as well but assumed that her faith would not have become a priority for her. I was wrong. As we caught up, she told me she was very involved at a local church, singing on the worship team and serving in the youth ministry. She could probably see the surprise on my face and explained: “Those mission trips—they really planted seeds in me; they were so important to my development.”
The juxtaposition of those two encounters was almost overwhelming. God was pounding me over the head with the message: Hey! Keep scattering those seeds! You keep being faithful, and you leave the fruit to me.
Youth ministry is perhaps the best example of the idea that the medium, or the person, is the message. What looks on the outside like merely hanging out or playing games, or even building a home for a family in Mexico, is so much more: creating a place where kids feel like they belong and are loved. Again, it may sound like a low bar, but these basic—though crucial—needs are things thousands of kids every year are not given. Every youth pastor and volunteer youth leader is doing so much more than just sharing a piece of information with a student; they are living out the message of God’s love in the way that they show students the love they’ve been shown.
Youth Ministry Is Just Ministry
I still work at the same church, in a different role. Toward the end of my tenure as youth pastor, I sensed that my ability to engage and connect with teenagers in my late forties wasn’t the same as it had been in earlier years. I wanted to leave a year too soon rather than a year too late. We had the perfect person in place to take over, and the transition has been seamless. Thankfully, my successor likes having me around, so I get to make appearances with students from time to time, still trying to make sure that my weird is the good kind of weird.
I like what a senior pastor friend told me about his current view of ministry. A former youth pastor himself, he said, “I still do youth ministry, but I do it with adults—the adults just don’t know that.” So that’s what I do in my role managing small groups: I invite adults into the steady and beautiful stream of God’s love, scattering seeds where I can and occasionally stepping into adults’ broken lives, where time-travelling Tim maybe wasn’t there to go back and alter the future.
The added bonus for me is the growing number of former youth group students currently raising their kids at the church. I’m not a grandfather yet, but I sort of already feel like one. What gives me joy is knowing that I’ve passed the baton to another youth pastor who is energetically doing what I once did.
He’s being the time-travelling youth pastor redirecting troubled teenagers away from a life of pain.
He’s inviting churched kids to belong to the flowing stream of God’s mercy, to live a life of joy in following him.
And he’s constantly scattering seeds, not knowing which will land where, but expectant that some of the most beautiful plants are the slowest to grow.





